• Home
  • Blog
    • Audio Podcast Archive
    • Joinery
    • News & Ramblings
    • Projects
    • Q & A
    • Shop Tips
    • Tools
  • Videos
  • Online Classes
    • Foundations of Traditional Woodworking
RegisterLogin

Login with your site account

Lost your password?

Not a member yet? Register now

Register a new account

Are you a member? Login now

Bob Rozaieski Fine Woodworking
  • Home
  • Blog
    • Audio Podcast Archive
    • Joinery
    • News & Ramblings
    • Projects
    • Q & A
    • Shop Tips
    • Tools
  • Videos
  • Online Classes
    • Foundations of Traditional Woodworking

Joinery

Orientation Marks, Reference Marks, and Layout – Part 2

  • Posted by Bob Rozaieski
  • Categories Joinery, Shop Tips
  • Date June 23, 2020
  • Comments 2 comments
Reference Face and Edge

In my last post I discussed orientation marks.  In brief summary, orientation marks, like the cabinetmaker’s triangle, tell you where the parts go in the overall assembly.  However, orientation marks are not the same thing as reference marks, which are used to identify a flat, straight, and square face, edge and corner.  So today, I want to go over the reference marks.

If you come from the world of wood machining (like I did), you may be unaware of the usefulness of reference marks (like I was, before I started this whole hand tool journey 20 years ago).  That’s because today’s powered jointers and planers can machine boards so precisely parallel in width and thickness (at least when they’re set up well), that we can get away with using either face or edge as a reference when machining joinery.

Reference Face and Edge
The “squiggle” mark, sometimes called a pigtail, denotes the reference face. The “V”, sometimes called an arrow or carat, denotes the reference edge. Both marks originate at the adjoining arris and are located about the center of the length of the board.

Reference marks hearken back to a time before the power jointer and planer did the heavy milling work in most woodworking shops.  When all lumber had to be “four-squared” with hand planes, there was a process that was followed to do so, and the reference face and edge were an important result of this process.  However, even if the process was followed very precisely, due to the nature of hand work, there could be minor inconsistencies in width and thickness in the board.  These minor differences could wreak havoc on joinery without the use of reference surfaces.  However, by using reference surfaces properly, these minor inconsistencies in width and thickness would not have any impact on the joinery.

When “milling” lumber by hand, boards are first crosscut to rough length and ripped to rough width.  Then, one face of the board is planed flat, smooth, and without wind.  With the face planed, one of the edges is then planed straight and square to that face.  These two surfaces are then considered the reference face and edge, and are marked as such.  The face is typically marked with a loop like mark, sometimes called a pigtail, with the origin of the mark at the arris between the face and edge.  The edge is typically marked with a “V” shaped symbol, sometimes called an arrow or a carat, the apex of which would meet the face mark at the arris between the surfaces.  These two marks are generally located approximately centered along the long edge.

Reference Face and Edge
When using a square or marking gauge, the fence of the tool should only reference off of the reference face…

The purpose of these reference marks is to aid in the layout of precise joinery.  When a square or marking gauge is used to lay out the joinery on a part, it should only be referenced off of the reference face or the reference edge.  As long as only these two reference surfaces are used for layout tasks, the joinery layout will be square, precise, and consistent between parts.  If the non-reference surfaces are used, however, there is no guarantee.

Reference Face and Edge
…or the reference edge. This is the most precise way to lay out joinery by hand, especially if you “mill” all of your stock with hand planes.

Lets take a look at an example.  The board in the photos above was purposely cut with a taper in both width and thickness to simulate what a hand “milled” board might look like, though the tapers have been exaggerated for demonstration purposes.  Below, I drew two layout lines around the stock – let’s pretend that these are the shoulders of a tenon.  Shoulder “A” was laid out by referencing the square only on the reference face (marked with a pigtail) or the reference edge (facing down in the photo).  Notice how, regardless of the taper in width and thickness, the shoulder layout meets perfectly at the non-reference corner, ensuring that the tenon shoulder is perfectly square to the reference edge and face.  Shoulder “B”, on the other hand, was drawn using a different edge/face to reference the square on, for each mark.  As a result, the shoulder layout does not meet at the non-reference corner, indicating that something is not laid out properly, and that the joint will not be cut correctly if these layout lines are followed.

Reference Face and Edge
Shoulder “A” is a perfectly square tenon shoulder layout. Shoulder “B”, on the other hand, will result in a very out of square assembly.

But even this doesn’t tell the entire story.  Using reference surfaces is important, but it is also just as important that the correct reference surfaces be used.  My rule of thumb is that the joinery surface should be the reference surface in most cases.  I have found that there are very few exceptions to this rule.  For example, below is a dry assembled headboard for a bed that I am currently working on.  In this situation, my reference faces all face out, and my reference edges are all the edges where joinery is going to be cut.  This example is very similar to how a table would be built – the inside edges of the legs, where the mortises are cut, are the reference surfaces on the legs, and the bottom of the apron is the reference edge (the top of the apron is planed flush with the tops of the legs after assembly and therefore would not be the reference edge).

Reference Marks
With very few exceptions, the joinery surfaces should be the reference surfaces.

Similar principles apply when making casework, boxes, or doors.  The reference face of a case, or drawer, is the inside face, because that is what will ensure a square assembly (and will not be planed after assembly).  The reference edge would be the bottom of the drawer, or the front of the case. In a door, the inside edges of the rails and stiles are the reference edges and the outside faces are the reference faces.

So if you are having some trouble getting your pieces to assemble nice and square, try paying closer attention to the reference face and edge when orienting the parts for your project, and when laying out your joinery.  By referencing your layout tools off of fewer, more consistent surfaces, you stand a much better chance of your joinery being more precise, and your project coming together nice and square.

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)

Tag:Layout

author avatar
Bob Rozaieski

I'm a passionate woodworking enthusiast of over 30 years, with an interest in the methods of pre-industrial joiners and cabinetmakers. I'm a furniture maker, teacher, and author, and I share my thoughts and experiences with the goal of educating and inspiring others who are pursuing the craft of traditional woodworking. In addition to writing about and teaching traditional woodworking, I also build commission pieces for customers, and speak at woodworking shows and seminars.

Previous post

Orientation Marks, Reference Marks, and Layout - Part 1
June 23, 2020

Next post

HTT056 - Taking Your Woodworking to the Next Level
July 1, 2020

    2 Comments

  1. Willard
    June 23, 2020
    Reply

    Just a minor detail: the reference edge mark (the caret) should only occupy about half the width of the reference edge. If it goes all the way across, then it can be mistaken for the top half of a carpenter’s triangle if one is not careful (if you were laying out 4 sides of a drawer for example). In the same, but reciprocal, way the carpenter’s triangle in this particular case is never carried across the full width of the reference edge (if it is being laid out there) because it can be mistaken for a caret in a moment of inattention. If the stock is being laid in such a manner that the reference edge mark and the carpenter’s triangle mark are on the same edge (and both would generally be in the middle of the stock), b e sure to place them side by side and they will be easy to distinguish.

    • Bob Rozaieski
      June 24, 2020
      Reply

      Thanks! That’s also a good argument/justification for using the French version of the cabinetmaker’s triangle. The additional line bisecting the triangle helps to distinguish it from a caret.

Join the Discussion Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe!Get Notified Whenever We Publish New Content

Would you like to receive notifications when new content is added to the site? Just enter your email address below and click "Subscribe" to get on the notification list. Don't worry, we'll never share your email with anyone. It'll be our little secret!

Search

Categories

  • Audio
  • Joinery
  • News & Ramblings
  • Projects
  • Q & A
  • Shop Tips
  • Tools
  • Videos

Popular Classes

English Workbench

English Workbench

Free
Hand Saw Foundations

Hand Saw Foundations

Free
Hand Plane Foundations

Hand Plane Foundations

Free

About

  • About
  • Testimonials

Links

  • RSS Feed
  • YouTube

Information

  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy

Support

  • Contact

Copyright © 2015-2022 Bob Rozaieski Fine Woodworking

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy